ACLU: American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio
Keeping America Safe and Free

Search and Seizure Due Process

Updated 09.24.08  No matter who wins the 2008 election, the ACLU will have its work cut out. The steady erosion of civil liberties -- carried out in the name of the  “war on terror” -- will take years to reverse. Among the most egregious abuses of power: the mistreatment of military detainees and warrantless searches.

What’s Happening Nationally

Military Detainees
The House and Senate both voted in October 2006 to allow the Administration to:

  • decide for itself what types of interrogation techniques constitute “torture,” even when they are prohibited under the Geneva Convention;
  • continue trying “unlawful enemy combatants” before military tribunals, which the U.S. Supreme Court rejected in June 2006 in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld.  READ MORE»
  • remove constitutional habeas protections that would allow detainees to challenge the basis for their detentions in court; and
  • permit the continued use of secret evidence and torture-induced testimony against detainees.

Recently, however, the courts have begun to challenge the legal rationale behind these abuses. In June 2008, the Supreme Court rejected a centerpiece of the Bush Administration's crumbling Guantanamo policy for the third time in four years when it reaffirmed detainees' right to habeas corpus, enabling them to challenge the basis for their detention. Read national ACLU Legal Director Steven R. Shapiro's statement here.

Search and Seizure
In July 2008, Congress passed and President Bush signed into law The FISA Amendments Act of 2008. As a result, the secret warrantless surveillance program approved by President Bush in 2001 is now legalized. The federal government also gained additional spying powers, including the authority to monitor Americans’ overseas calls. A few days later, the ACLU sued over the new law, representing a wide range of plaintiffs from Amnesty International to The Nation magazine. Find more information on this historic lawsuit, including legal documents, here.

In June 2008, civil liberties and business groups testified at a hearing before Congress about the Department of Homeland Security's practice of routinely searching the laptop computers of travelers returning to the U.S. Investigators at airports may scrutinize private emails, medical information and financial records that have been stored in a traveler's laptop, Blackberry or iPhone. Read comments on the ACLU's blog.

PATRIOT Act
Reauthorized in 2006, the USA PATRIOT Act contains a number of provisions that impact our due process rights.  Read more on the national ACLU website. go»


What's Happening in Ohio

 
ACLU of Ohio Litigation

Warshak v. United States
In March 2005, the federal government began investigating a company owned by Steven Warshak. The FBI and U.S. Postal Inspection Service secured a sealed order under the Stored Communications, Act, enabling them to secretly search and seize Mr. Warshak's email with the help of several Internet service providers. Mr. Warshak filed a lawsuit claiming Fourth Amendment violations. READ MORE»

Elkins, et. al. v. Bucyrus City School District et. al.
In April 2008, nine Bucyrus Middle School students were subjected to an illegal strip search by the school in an attempt to find cigarettes. The search took place after four of the students were seen across the street from the school, smoking. The students attempted to hide themselves among five other students, and all nine of them were then detained by the school and strip-searched. No cigarettes were found. On September 17, 2008, the ACLU of Ohio filed suit challenging the school district's illegal strip searches of the students. Read the press release.

Juvenile Waiver of Appointed Counsel
In October 2007, the Ohio Supreme Court, in a case known as In Re: Spears, ruled that the waiver of counsel by a juvenile (Spears) was invalid because his rights were not adequately explained to him. The Court affirmed that the appointment of counsel is mandatory in all cases where a juvenile does not have a parent or guardian available for advice, and allows juveniles to waive counsel only if the decision is made voluntarily, knowingly and intelligently. The ACLU of Ohio, along with several coalition partners, filed an amicus brief in this case. Click here to read the Court’s full decision.

Read more about juveniles’ access to counsel.

Legislation

On June 27, 2008, Governor Strickland signed Senate Bill 17 into law. This new law requires individuals suspected of DUI to submit to testing of their bodily fluids, without a warrant, when they’ve been convicted of DUI at least twice before. The new law went into effect on September 30, 2008. Read our press release here.

Read testimony against this legislation delivered to the Ohio House Criminal Justice Committee by ACLU of Ohio Legal Director Jeff Gamso. 


Resources

December 10, 2008 will mark the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR).

Do you know what to do if you are stopped by the police, taken to a police station for questioning, arrested, or asked if the police can enter your home?  Read What to Do If You’re Stopped by the Police go» 

To print a version for distribution click here.
 

Lieutenant Commander Charles Swift, who represented a Guantanamo Bay detainee in the landmark U.S. Supreme Court case Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, spoke at a Cleveland ACLU gathering on Oct. 8, 2006. To learn more about Lt Comm. Swift and his work to bring justice to those detained by the government, click on the links below.

Justice for Guantanamo
Ed Likover Memorial Lecture, Cleveland, October 8, 2006 - MP4 video file

The Cost of Doing Your Duty
New York Times, October 11, 2006

Detainees' Military Lawyer Forced Out of Service
National Public Radio, October 12, 2006
 
Students! Know Your Rights
Use this guide in conjunction with your school's handbook. go»

Read “Bigger Monster, Weaker Chains: The Growth of an American Surveillance Society” explaining how our activities are increasingly being tracked and recorded. go»
 
Visit the national ACLU’s web page on criminal justice.

Read Search & Seizure/Due Process related press releases and news articles in our News Center.